As October progresses, the situation surrounding James McCarthy’s departure from Celtic remains a mystery. Despite leaving the club over the summer, there’s been no official word or farewell from Celtic, leaving fans puzzled. Unlike other players, even those with minor roles, McCarthy’s exit went unremarked, raising questions about why the club has kept silent on his departure. This quiet exit has sparked curiosity, given McCarthy’s stature and experience in the squad.

James McCarthy, a lifelong Celtic supporter, joined the club in 2021 during Ange Postecoglou’s squad overhaul. His signing was met with optimism, but injuries plagued his time at Celtic, limiting him to just 27 appearances over two seasons. By last season, McCarthy had fallen completely out of favor, with Brendan Rodgers showing little interest in integrating him into the squad. He was frequently spotted training alone in the gym, a stark contrast to the main group, signaling that his time at the club was nearing an end.

Despite the challenges James McCarthy faced at Celtic, his departure stands out due to the unusual lack of acknowledgment from the club. Typically, even fringe players receive a farewell post on social media, but in McCarthy’s case, there’s been complete silence. Whether this reflects a quiet, mutual agreement to part ways or an oversight by Celtic, the absence of any public gratitude feels conspicuous. It leaves a sense of unfinished business in how his exit has been handled, especially for a player who joined with such high expectations.

Although James McCarthy’s tenure at Celtic didn’t deliver the on-field impact many anticipated, his signing stemmed from a heartfelt desire to contribute to the club he loved as a child. It’s a peculiar conclusion for a lifelong Celtic fan whose dream move ultimately fell short, raising questions about why the club has opted not to acknowledge his departure.

From the outset, the signing seemed unusual, especially considering Celtic’s decision to hire a manager focused on high-energy, relentless football. McCarthy, with his injury history and style, was never truly suited to this approach. Adding to the mystery, he hasn’t surfaced anywhere else since leaving Celtic—no announcements of retirement or a new club—making his exit even stranger.